Pages

Friday, September 25, 2015

The First Law of Motion

My son and I were walking back from the library where he had just spent two straight hours playing his favorite video game (and was consequently in a mellow mood). 

As we marched on the pavement, we talked at first of this and that, chit-chat. Then it occurred to me this could be a good chance to strike up a conversation about something they'd be touching on at school soon.

"This guy, Newton," I started. "So he has three laws of motion, right?" 

"Right," he said, a little cautiously, but not too perturbed. He is used to my habit of starting conversations like this rather abruptly.

"Do you happen to know what they are?" 

He seemed a little dubious, so I backed up and decided to go even slower.

"Ok, let's talk about just the first one. It basically says objects that are at rest don't move, and if they are moving at a constant speed, they stay that way unless something acts on them to change their motion."

He nodded, this seemed familiar. "Because of their momentum," he noted.

I had noticed his laces were untied and pointed it out to him. We stopped by a fence while he put up his shoes to fix them.



"Yes, momentum, or..." I got a little confused myself, watching him. He was in fact right, but I wasn't sure in the moment if momentum was the right word to use about this law, so I said, "well, I think Inertia is the word we want. We say the objects have inertia, inertia of rest or inertia of motion."

I went on: "Do you know the ancient Greeks had their own version of this law, and it was rather different?"

He looked up, interested. We have been watching a very entertaining history TV show these days and the Groovy Greeks, he knows, are always an interesting lot.

"They thought objects prefer to be always in motion unless something acts on them to stop them."

He chewed on this, as I went on to say,  "But we know this isn't true. If you did this experiment in zero gravity and in a vacuum, for example, an object could stay still with nothing touching or acting on it."

Digressing here a bit, he said, "Oh, you know, my science teacher once got to experience zero-gravity. She said it was not a pleasant experience. Your insides feel like they're not supported."

"Hmm...," I said, "very interesting. I hadn't thought of how it would feel." 

He ran off at this point ahead of me. I took it as a signal he had gotten bored of the discussion we were having about Newton, but he smiled and clarified he didn't want to miss the chance to catch the light, so he had run ahead to push the button on time. Indeed, the walk signal showed up right away and we could cross. 

Seeing that I still had his attention, I continued as we crossed the road, "So, to them, the Greeks, every object they saw preferred to move and would only stop if prevented from moving. In particular they noticed objects always want to fall down, that is to say, move downwards, unless they were held up."

I gestured with my hands to illustrate this. We walked past some tall grasses, then a big box intended to collect clothing donations.

He thought about it a bit and remarked perceptively: "I see how what they were thinking makes a lot of sense. Imagine a rock at the very edge of a sheer cliff. It wouldn't even want to stay at the ground at the top of the cliff, it would rather fall even further down if it could. So the cliff is holding it in place."

"Right."

He nodded, chewing it further in his head.

I then asked, "Do you think the Greeks were wrong?"

He said "yes," right away.

I clarified a bit further: "I mean, if you think about the two different theories, they do agree on one point, that an object in motion could be stopped by a force acting on it. But they actually disagree about what would happen if an object was not moving and nothing was touching it or pulling/pushing at it. The Greek version says that is simply not possible, while Newton's law says it would stay still."

I continued, "the Greek version of this law applied to everything they encountered in their daily lives. We simply don't see such an object in our everyday experience. So for what we come across in our every day experience, both Newton's theory and the Greek theory are valid."

He responded, "I see. I kinda sympathize with them, they simply didn't know any better." 

"Exactly!" I said, "given what they were able to observe, their explanation, their scientific theory was adequate and consistent. In fact, perhaps it was even more satisfying because it doesn't invoke something intangible called a 'Force', the objects in their world-view are held back from moving by other objects such as the ground or the fluid air."

I changed gears a little, "Similarly, Newton's theory was adequate for his time, but in fact now we know even he was wrong. His theory offers a good approximation but is not quite right."

He seemed surprised. "I had no idea! Newton was wrong? But he's so famous!"

I said, "well, Einstein's (general) theory contradicts Newton. Newton believed Gravity was a direct interaction between the planet and objects like the apple. But Einstein didn't believe in what he called 'spooky action at a distance' ."

"Then why do they teach kids about Newton's Physics?"

"Because he wasn't completely wrong. His physics provides a pretty good approximation of most phenomena we deal with. And it would be too hard to teach kids in school about Einstein's theories."

He laughed, no doubt at the silliness of kids being taught something wrong on purpose in schools everywhere because the truth would be harder to explain.

"Basically, unlike Newton, who saw  saw  Gravity as a Force, Einstein saw it as resulting from the curvature of space-time."

We were home. He rested, tired, on the couch, but he was still looking at me, clearly confused by this complicated expression "curvature of space-time". 

"A somewhat intuitive analogy or model of what Einstein was saying is to think of the planet as a bowling ball on a piece of cloth, and any object near it such as a smaller ball will fall in towards the bowling ball because the fabric will have been reshaped in a way to make that happen. Einstein's point was that the planet doesn't call out to an apple at a distance to exert a force on it, just as the Bowling ball doesn't 'talk' to the smaller ball, rather the planet's mass distorts space and time in such a way that the natural motion of the ball leads it towards the planet."

"Ah! Remember that YouTube video we saw? They also showed how the smaller ball would loop round and round around the bowling ball if it was moving at a speed initially."


"Right. I remember it, that was a cool video!"

We both stopped talking, thinking in parallel, perhaps, about that shared memory.
Pleased, but thinking now of other things, he leaped from the couch, glided across the room, bounded up the stairs, and vanished.

*** 

His mother told me later he had narrated to her upstairs how Newton was wrong and told her excitedly about the bowling ball model of Einstein's theory of gravity... I am so glad our conversation had stirred something in him that he had wanted to share with others. 


P.S.: My conversation with my son was inspired by an excellent article by Arthur Steiner titled "The Story of Force: from Aristotle to Einstein". As the author writes, "a history-based exposure to the conceptual development of Newtonian mechanics is superior to a conventional textbook-centered approach, because it is contextual, shows the intellectual struggle involved in scientific thinking and relates better to students' knowledge and experience." I couldn't agree more.

Credits: images from Wikimedia; thanks to Sean C. for pointing me at the video by Feynman.  

46 comments:

Packers And Movers Lingampally Hyderabad said...

i really like your blog, thanks for share...
please visit are website..
Packers And Movers Hyderabad

Packers And Movers Kukatpally Hyderabad

Jual Mobil Bekas said...

An excellent way to pass time model collecting can help you to clear your mind and relieve a bit of stress. Miniature model cars are no exception. There are actually a few benefits to collecting these mini masterpieces that you might not realize when first considering them as an option.

packers and movers jaipur said...


Packers and Movers Bangalore for 100% Affordable and Professional Packers and Movers in Bangalore. Compare Charges of Movers and Packers, Household Shifting Services at. Packers And Movers Jaipur

packers and movers jaipur said...


Packers and Movers Bangalore for 100% Affordable and Professional Packers and Movers in Bangalore. Compare Charges of Movers and Packers, Household Shifting Services at. Packers And Movers Jaipur

Packers And Movers Mumbai said...

Excellent Post...I must thank you for this informative news....
This is my first time go to see at here and i am really pleassant to read
all at one place
Packers and Movers Mumbai

Packers And Movers Mumbai said...

Packers And Movers Beed Maharashtra
Packers And Movers Mumbai to Kolkata

packers and movers chennai said...

I must say you had done a tremendous job,I appreciate all your efforts.Thanks alot for your writings......
Packers And Movers Chennai

packers and movers chennai said...

Packers And Movers Chennai to Patna
Packers And Movers Nilgiris Tamilnadu

Packers And Movers Hyderabad said...

Excellent Post...I must thank you for this informative news....
This is my first time go to see at here and i am really pleassant to read
all at one place
Packers And Movers Hyderabad

Packers And Movers Hyderabad said...

Packers And Movers Hyderabad to Chennai
Packers And Movers Hyderabad To Pune
Packers And Movers Hyderabad to Bhubaneswar
Packers And Movers Hyderabad to Bhopal
Packers And Movers Hyderabad to Bangalore
Packers And Movers Hyderabad to Mumbai
Packers And Movers Hyderabad to Gurgaon

kiran negi said...

RRB ALP Recruitment
Latest RRB ALP Recruitment
Upcoming RRB ALP Recruitment

kiran negi said...

Upcoming 12th pass government jobs
12th pass government jobs

Job Alerts said...

Hello sir, your web site is lovingly serviced and saved as much as date. So it should be, thanks for sharing this with us.
i also found some helpful sites like yours.


HSSC jobs
RPSC jobs
fresh job alert
WPSC jobs
IBPS jobs
SSC jobs
West Bengal Police jobs
RRB recruitment
RRC recruitment 2018

cbse 10th results 2018 said...


cbse 10 results 2018
10 class results 2018
2018 cbse results
12th class results 2018
cbse board results 2018
haryana board 10th&12th results 2018
uttar pardesh 12th board results 2018
hos board 10 results 2018
rbse board 10 results 2018
pbse board 10 results 2018
tamilnadu 10 results 2018
maharashtra 10 results 2018
Bihar 10th & 12th results 2018
cbse 10th & 12th results 2018
Kerala board 10 results 2018

best yoga exercise to inhale in body said...

Hello sir, your web site is lovingly serviced and saved as much as date. So it should be, thanks for sharing this with us.
i also found some helpful sites like yours.



Yoga Poses
Yoga Pose & health Benefits
yoga for meditation
yoga for weight loss
yoga for lower back pain
yoga for beginners
hatha yoga poses
bikram yoga poses types
yoga for inner peace
yoga videos
moksha yoga types
different yoga posture & images
Best yoga exercise to inhale in body
Ramdev yoga asana benefit
yoga types for men & women

Packers And Movers Bangalore said...

We Provide List Of Best And Affordable 100% Safe Packers And Movers Bangalore For Local Shifting. Professional, Trusted And Verified Movers And Packers With Price List.
Packers And Movers Bangalore

online check process voter id 2018-19 said...

your web site is lovingly serviced and saved as much as date. So it should be, thanks for sharing this with us.
i also found some helpful sites like yours.



Voter Id Card
online check voter id status by name
online apply Voter Id Card Registration
Voter Id Correction
online duplicate Voter Id Card
online check process voter id 2018-19
apply for online voter card
check voter id status by date of birth
Maharashtra Voter ID Card Registration
Haryana Voter ID Card Registration

Best Tourism said...

This is a wonderful article, Given so much info in it, You can see travel nearby best tourist place Best Honeymoon Destination in this page.

Travel Nearby
Best Tourist Place in India
Tourist Place in Jaipur
Beautifull Hill Station for Couples
Tourist Place Near Maharasthra
Weekend Destination Near Mumbai
Weekend Destination near Delhi
Best hill station in India
Weekend Gateways Near Banglore
Weekend Gateways Near Hyderabad
Places to visit in Rajasthan
Places to visit in Agra

Packers Movers Chennai said...


Really impressive post. I read it whole and going to share it with my social circules. I enjoyed your article and planning to rewrite it on my own blog.
Packers And Movers in Chennai

Modicare marketing business said...

Thanks for posting this awesome article. I’m a long time reader but I’ve never been compelled to leave a comment.online-registration-for-modicare-consultant
Modicare-success-story
Modicare-achievers-list

Packers and Movers Bangalore said...

Packers And Movers Bangalore Local Household Shifting Service, Get Free Best Price Quotes Local Packers and Movers in Bangalore List , Compare Charges, Save Money And Time
Packers And Movers in Bangalore

Packers and Movers Bangalore said...

Packers And Movers Bangalore Local Household Shifting Service, Get Free Best Price Quotes Local Packers and Movers in Bangalore List , Compare Charges, Save Money And Time
Packers And Movers in Bangalore

Travel nearby said...


Thanks have been given the opportunity to comment. Hopefully what you provided is useful for all those who need them. Visit my website if you want to know more about.
Latest breaking News in India
Top Stories News Headlines
Politics News
Politics lifestyle
Actress lifestyle
New Hindi Movies Celebrity Photos

Packers And Movers Chennai said...

Packers and Movers Chennai Give Safe and Reliable ***Household Shifting Services in Chennai with Reasonable ###Packers and Movers Price Quotation. We Provide Household Shifting, Office Relocation, ✔✔✔Local and Domestic Transportation Services, Affordable and Reliable Shifting Service Charges @
Packers And Movers in Chennai

Uidai help enquiry said...


Hi there, I enjoy reading through your article.
I like to write a little comment to support you.


E aadhar card
Aadhar card download
Check Aadhar Card Status by name & moblie no.
e aadhar card update
aadhaar card correction

shekhawati kirshi farm said...

This is really a great support for the latest adviser from online. Really a supportive work for writing a good article.Any one can enjoy it with the style of writing.
Shekhawati kirshi farm
Organic farming
Top organic farm
Best organic farm in Rajasthan
Top organic farm in India

Travel nearby said...

Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all of us you actually know what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Please also visit my site.

Most Famous Beaches and Dams in Kerala
Places to visit in Trivandrum
Places to visit in Kochi (Cochin)
Places to visit in Idukki
Tourist Places to Visit in Devikulam
Beautifull Hill Station Munnar for Couples
Tourist Place Near Kumarakom
Weekend Destination near Kovalam
Tourist Places to Visit in Kollam
Most Famous Hotels & Honeymoon Resorts in Munnar

Travel nearby said...


E aadhar card
Aadhar card download
Check Aadhar Card Status by name & moblie no.
e aadhar card update
Uidai help enquiry
Aadhar Card Correction

Travel nearby said...

Tourist Places to Visit in Nainital
Beautifull Hill Station Auli for Couples
Tourist Place Near Bhimtal
Most Beautiful Places To Visit in Ranikhet
Tourist Places to Visit in Dehradun
Places to visit in Dhanaulti

Travel nearby said...

Hey there, You have done an incredible job. I will certainly digg it and in my view suggest to my friends.
I'm confident they'll be benefited from this website.
Home Loan Emi Calculator
Car loan Emi Calculator
Personal Loan Emi Calculator
Education Loan Emi Calculators
Two Wheeler Loan Emi Calculator
Credit Card Loan Emi Calculator

Travel nearby said...

Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all of us you actually know what you are talking about! Bookmarked. Please also visit my site.
StunningTourist Places to Visit in Jaisalmer
Beautifull Hill Station Udaipur for Couples
Incredible Places To Visit in Mount Abu
Alluring Tourist Places To Visit in Jodhpur
Most Tourist Places to Visit in Pushkar
Amazing Tourist Places To Visit in Chittorgarh

Packers Movers in Mumbai said...

Packers and Movers in Dadar
Packers and Movers in Thane West
Packers and Movers in Thane
Packers and Movers in Panvel
Packers and Movers in Kamothe
Packers and Movers in Vashi
Packers and Movers in Chembur
Packers and Movers in Jogeshwari
Packers and Movers in Kharghar
Packers and Movers in Dombivli

Movers and Packers in Hyderabad said...

Movers and Packers in Kondapur
Movers and Packers in Gachibowli
Movers and Packers in Kukatpally
Movers and Packers in Chanda Nagar
Movers and Packers in Manikonda

Packers and Movers Jaipur said...

Get Packers and Movers Jaipur List of Top Reliable, 100% Affordable, Verified and Secured Service Provider. Get Free ###Packers and Movers Jaipur Price Quotation instantly and Save Cost and Time. Packers and Movers Jaipur ???Reviews and Compare Charges for household Shifting, Home/Office Relocation, ***Car Transportation, Pet Relocation, Bike SHifting @
Packers And Movers Jaipur

Travel nearby said...

Most Beautiful Tourist Places To Visit in Assam
Beautiful Places To Visit in Guwahati
Stunning Tourist Places To Visit in Barpeta
Amazing Places To Visit in Goalpara
Most Beautiful Places To Visit in Dispur
Most Beautiful Places To Visit in Digboi
Stunning Tourist Places To Visit in Jorhat
Most Amazing Places To Visit in Karimganj

Travel nearby said...


Beautiful Tourist Places To Visit in Meghalaya
Amazing Places To Visit in Tura
Best Tourist Places To Visit in Jowai
Most Beautiful Places To Visit in Cherrapunji
Most Famous Places To Visit in Shillong

Travel nearby said...

Thanks for sharing an amazing post.

Top 5 Most Famous Tourist Places To Visit in Spain
A Complete Information About Tour to Colosseum Amphitheatre
A Complete Guided Tour to Leaning Tower of Pisa, Italy
Best Tourist Attraction & Things To Do in Palazzo Pitti Tours, Florence
Top 6 Most Famous Tourist Places & Museums in Venice, Italy
Important Things to know about Leaning Tower of Pisa
A Brief Story of Sagrada Familia History & About Antoni Gaudi
A Complete Guide To Sagrada Familia & Park Guell Tour

Travel nearby said...

Top 6 Alluring Tourist Places To Visit in Changlang & Things To Do
Top 5 Stunning Tourist Places To Visit in Dirang & Things To Do
Top 7 Best Tourist Places To Visit in Itanagar & Things To Do
Top 7 Incredible Tourist Places To Visit in Roing
Top 8 Best Tourist Places To Visit in Tawang
Most Famous Tourist Places To Visit in Ziro & Things To Do
Beautiful Tourist Places To Visit in Pasighat
Best Tourist Places To Visit in Daporijo

Packers And Movers Chennai said...

Packers and Movers Chennai Give Safe and Reliable ***Household Shifting Services in Chennai with Reasonable ###Packers and Movers Price Quotation. We Provide Household Shifting, Office Relocation, ✔✔✔Local and Domestic Transportation Services, Affordable and Reliable Shifting Service Charges @
Packers And Movers Chennai

rson9841 said...

Great blog. Keep Blogging!!
Mba Assignment Writing Service
Economics Homework Help
Do My Accounting Homework
Accounting Homework Help
Finance homework help

Anonymous said...

MGLSarees.com - Shop Best Mangalagiri Handloom Cotton and Pattu Sarees | Dress Materials - Shop for the exclusive stylish and ethnic handloom sarees online at great price. ✯Free Shipping. Select from the best range of womens Dress Materials. Buy handloom silk and pattu sarees online, buy exclusive handloom cotton saris online, purchase handloom cotton sarees online, latest designer handloom saris, attractive prices, worldwide express shipping. MGLSarees - Online Mangalagiri Handloom Cotton and Pattu Sarees | Dress Materials - Online Shopping Website, Mangalagiri
Mangalagiri Sarees and Dress Materials
Mangalagiri Pattu Sarees
Mangalagiri Dress Materials

Ufo 3D said...

https://ufo3d.com

Anonymous said...

Bihar Amin Admit Card
Bundelkhand University Admit Card
Lekhpal Recruitment 2020

Mahi Chopra said...

I am an exceptionally adoring mumbai escorts lady. Mumbai call girls can invariably remember and my name is additionally exceptionally exceptional and a part of your diversion will play by my sexy appearance.

Punjabi Call Girls in Mumbai | Mumbai Escort | Independent Mumbai Escorts | Independent Escorts in Mumbai | Mumbai Escorts Agency | Mumbai Escorts Service | Escorts Agency in Mumbai | Escorts Mumbai | Mumbai Female Escorts|Mumbai Escorts

Best Packers and Movers said...

Very helpful website useful article thanq soo much sir


packers and movers


packers and movers vijayawada


packers and movers visakhapatnam


packers and movers guntur


packers and movers tenali


packers and movers in vijayawada


packers and movers in Visakhapatnam


packers and movers in Guntur


packers and movers in tenali

packers and movers near me

packers and movers


packers and movers vijayawada


packers and movers visakhapatnam


packers and movers guntur



packers and movers tenali


packers and movers in vijayawada


packers and movers in Visakhapatnam


packers and movers in Guntur


packers and movers in tenali


packers and movers near me

packers and movers

packers and movers vijayawada

packers and movers visakhapatnam

packers and movers guntur


packers and movers tenali

packers and movers in vijayawada


packers and movers in Visakhapatnam


packers and movers in Guntur


packers and movers in tenali


packers and movers near me

best packers and movers


best packers and movers vijayawada


best packers and movers visakhapatnam


best packers and movers guntur


best packers and movers tenali


best packers and movers in vijayawada


best packers and movers in Visakhapatnam


best packers and movers in Guntur


packers and movers in tenali

packers and movers near me

Alex said...

They all return is a blog to understand with a little effort and only the students can do this struggle. So is the reason I will share this blog with the readers and the students. In this way we can increase the worth and quality of this blog with no effort. This is really a useful blog.
Homework Writing Service