Sunday, January 20, 2013

The Importance of Grace in Education

Francis Edward Su, a Professor of Mathematics at Harvey Mudd College, has made public the text of a stirring talk he recently gave upon accepting (a clearly well-deserved!) teaching award, in which he expounds on the "Lesson of Grace in Teaching".

He summarizes the "lesson of grace" in two statements: "1. Your accomplishments are NOT what make you a worthy human being. 2.  You learn this lesson by receiving GRACE: good things you didn't earn or deserve, but you're getting them anyway. "

His definition and exposition of "grace" crystallizes beautifully what I have felt and experienced myself but could not articulate so well. I will never forget the mentors in graduate school who offered me warm, unconditional, support and advice. I am grateful to have the chance to pay it forward in my own interactions with students, and do my best to treat them as worthy individuals deserving of encouragement, advice, help, or as they most often need, a friendly, non-judgmental, ear.

We live in an achievement-oriented society, particularly in academia, with its pervasive emphasis on competition, external evaluation, recognition. Much harm is done by this system, not only to those students who do poorly, but counter-intuitively, even to those who do well, because it reinforces a fundamentally flawed connection between self-worth and achievement.

I wrote about something related a while ago in the context of the "impostor syndrome" (the name given to the feelings of inferiority that many students suffer from while doing the Ph.D.).

I wrote in that post that "having given the matter much thought over the years, I feel that what exacerbates the impostor syndrome, or perhaps even gives rise to it in the first place, is adopting the world view that ties one's sense of self-worth to one's achievements and treats achievement as the goal of one's efforts." I argued that it is important for students to cultivate a mindset that places a greater emphasis on learning and discovery as ends in themselves rather than as a means to success through achievement.

Francis's talk calls upon educators to think differently, and to treat the individuals they encounter with grace, regardless of their academic performance as measured by tests and exams. It is a call that, if heeded, would have a tremendously positive impact on the lives of many.


Chih-ping said...

At the MIT diversity summit 2013 ( a couple days ago, Valerie Young gave a wonderful keynote address about impostor syndrome. Two things I found interesting:

1. Top universities no longer adopt the mindset of "look to your left, look to your right, because one of you won't be here by the end of the year." Instead, they let students understand the notion of impostor syndrome on the first day of class, and help them get through it.

2. According to statistics, the percentage of female professionals having impostor syndrome is slightly higher than that of male professionals; but the difference is not much. In one category male professionals are more likely to have impostor syndrome: Male professors.

Bhaskar said...

Very interesting. Following up on your comment brought to my attention that Dr. Valerie Young has written a book titled The Secret Thoughts of Successful Women . She writes that "While the impostor syndrome is not unique to women, they are more likely to agonize over tiny mistakes and blame themselves for failure, see even constructive criticism as evidence of their shortcomings; and chalk up their accomplishments to luck rather than skill... It can make her more risk-averse and less self-promoting than her male peers, which can hurt her future success."

candorschool said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Unknown said...

Hi,Thanks for the information about this Really nice Post.
Medical Entrance Exam 2017
Neet 2017 admit-card
RRB Results 2016 – 2017

NEET2017 said...

NEET Exam dates
NEET Eligibility Criteria 
NEET Application form
NEET Application fee details


Thanks for sharing this. For MEDICAL ADMISSIONS in abroad , there are many choices like MBBS IN LATVIA ,
and so on....

Unknown said...

Nice article thanks for sharing with us.
RRB Recruitment 2017


Tell Me how To Check My ssc chsl admit card .i’m Going to many sites but can’t find any information about ssc chsl admit card .pls tell me asap .and some sites i’m going to check my SSC CHSL Admit Card

Unknown said...

Best Spoken English coaching. A very student friendly environment.

Leading IELTS training. Guaranteed results.

Unknown said...

Nice article thanks for sharing with us.
RRB Recruitment 2017

Anonymous said...

Click here to check Maharashtra ssc, hsc result 2017.

SRK ROCKS said...

Patwari Admit Card

Patwari Result

Anonymous said...

Click here to get karnataka sslc result 2017.

Anonymous said...

Tamil Nadu HSC Result will declare the results.

Anonymous said...

Click here to get HSC Result Gujarat at official website.

rchandra said...

The Winds Of Winter Release Date
Game Of Thrones Season 7 Trailer Watch Online
A Song Of Ice And Fire PDF

Anonymous said...

Nice article Mr. Bhaskar. Very impressive.
Reference for students who looking for MBBS in abroad.MBBS in abroad

akshaya said...

This information is impressive. I am inspired with your post writing style & how continuously you describe this topic. Eagerly waiting for your new blog keep doing more.
IELTS Classes in Mumbai
TOEFL Coaching Centres in Chennai
IELTS Coaching in Mumbai
German Language Classes in Chennai
Best IELTS Coaching in Mumbai
Spoken English in ChennaiIELTS Center in Mumbai
IELTS Coaching in Chennai
IELTS Training in Mumbai

Packers and Movers in Hyderabad said...

Hi! Thanks a lot! Excellent article.
Movers and Packers in Kondapur
Movers and Packers in Gachibowli
Movers and Packers in Kukatpally
Movers and Packers in Chanda Nagar
Movers and Packers in Manikonda

Movers and Packers in Mumbai said...

Amazing blog. Thanks for sharing.
Packers and Movers in Dadar
Packers and Movers in Thane
Packers and Movers in Panvel
Packers and Movers in Kamothe
Packers and Movers in Vashi
Packers and Movers in Chembur
Packers and Movers in Jogeshwari
Packers and Movers in Kharghar
Packers and Movers in Dombivli

anonymous said...

The main enormous stunned give the Donald trump in the wake of winning the presidential race is that he restricted seven nations individuals who can't come to visit the USA and the purpose for this band is the psychological oppressor and you can to get educational task. This is totally at the base of the separation and Donald trump rehashes the history that made Hitler amid his life.

anonymous said...

In this one line, you give the solid message to your watchers. You give the boldness to the general population that don't lose your expectation since and here is easy way to get this post for good work. it is vital to discover your direction in the event that you lose your expectation, it is extremely hard to locate the most ideal way that you need.

anonymous said...

Excellent post! Perhaps he imagines that individuals will value his choice however he didn't that individuals require love and harmony and need essential things that are the commitment of the legislature and it is likewise your commitment but you can get redirected here for useful task. By and by, I have no worry to him yet my worry is the nation and individuals of the nation.

Anonymous said...

Such a good post for the students, It can turn the world a tremendously enhanced place to live in, as it site will turn the general open generously increasingly careful and capacity full. Thanks for sharing.

Anonymous said...

Good info you have added with theirs. It is the theory is that men are the money and persistently, a tad at any given moment money change over into the human. This click to read more site is just the theory and no one ponders the truth of this issue.

Lucky Patcher said...

whatsdog apk

luckys said...


luckys said...


tech zone said...

finance whatsapp groups

arun said...

kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees

seoexperts said...

Nice blog...this blog collect such as a good information and this is really very interesting and useful conten, Thank you for sharing such kind of information. it will help me to increase my knowledge you also chack my service allide movers and packers it's related to youer blog.thanks

Charli Smith said...

It seems to me that a person that is less educated has a better outlook on life and humanity,that person is more likely to help the next person in time of need than a person that is ,lets say a college graduate , or a lawyer , even politicians.