Pages

Thursday, October 23, 2014

On the Virtue of Putting the Cart before the Horse




You may have seen the above video by "DjSadhu" purporting to show how the motion of the planets would appear if we use a frame of reference with respect to which the sun is moving. If not, I'd encourage you to take a look. It's fascinating.

However, Phil Plait has posted an article on slate.com pointing out that this viral video is in fact scientifically incorrect, where he says:
It seems right, or looks cool, or appeals to some sense of how things should be. But how things should be and how they are don’t always overlap. The Universe is a pretty cool place, and works using a fairly well-regulated set of rules. We call those rules physics, they’re written in the language of math, and trying to understand all that is science.
My first reaction on seeing Phil's article was, "Yes, that makes sense. As he says, 'not everything cool is science...' "

But then I saw a post by a friend of mine, who was a former faculty member (now working in industry), in response to Phil's article. He wrote that Phil was, well, a "killjoy. Perhaps, [a] scientifically accurate killjoy, but still a killjoy. " His point was that the original video, despite its inaccuracies, served to spark the imagination of many people (as of now, that video has received over 2 million hits!) and that Phil could have offered his corrections in a more constructive spirit rather than proclaiming loudly the incorrectness of the original video.

Reflecting on his comments, I think my friend is really on to something.

Just recently some colleagues and I were having an interesting conversation about why college is boring for many students and we figured out that we college faculty may all be killjoys.

Faculty, due to both nature and nurture the most pedantic of creatures, would rather say something careful and provably correct than show something cool of dubious "truthiness". We would rather build up little by little from abstract fundamentals in the vain (often unfulfilled due to lack of time) hope of reaching eventually concepts one can relate to. We are not inclined to let our students encounter something half-baked that they find amazing and thought-provoking, and then work from that spark of excitement towards the truth.

It is worth pausing to think whether our sneering dismissal of imprecise, careless thinking, our endless harping on rigor, our ceaseless skepticism (all qualities that are essential for our work as researchers, the very qualities we are recognized and lauded for by our peers) might sometimes get in the way of creating the best environment for our students to seek the truth on their own.

Now, let me clear, I am not arguing for teaching students cool-but-unscientific lies or even half-truths. If our own hunger for truth and the desire to share that drive with our students did not ultimately motivate us, we would not be in this line of work. But perhaps there is a place for the incorrect, the absurd, if it is cool enough to draw in the students' curiosity and their imagination, and inspire them to proceed further? It could serve as a starting point for a more careful and rigorous investigation.

Sometimes at least, we should place the cart before the horse (or the sun in front of the planets) because that is unusual and striking, enough to make one stop, stare and think.








84 comments:

Banglore Shifting Solutions said...


I must say you had done a tremendous job,I appreciate all your efforts.Thanks alot for your writings......Waiting for a new . please visit:Packers And Movers Bangalore

Aliabhatt said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
amaze244 said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Madhuri Dixit said...

Great post. you have pointed out some fantastic points . I likewise think this s a very wonderful website.

blouse designs for silk sarees
fake nail designs
bridal blouse designs
golden brocade blouse designs
happy birthday uncle images
http://www.fashioncluba.com/

Unknown said...

happy easter background images
happy easter
happy easter clip art
happy easter bunny coloring pages

Unknown said...

happy mothers day daughter images
mothers day quotes from son
mothers day cartoon pictures
mothers day images

Think High said...

I remember my mother's prayers and they have always followed me. They have clung to me all my life.

Read more quotes at ....http://happyeasterimages2017.com/mothers-day-mothers-day-quotes/

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
BittuSingh said...

Meaningful post …..Thanks for sharing
Memorial Day Messages Quotes
Memorial Day Weekend 2017

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Unknown said...

Thanks for the information about this Really nice Post.
Happy Memorial Day Images
memorial day quotes for soldiers
happy memorial day 2017 images

Shrutika Verma said...

Memorial Day Thank You Quotes
Memorial Day Decor Ideas
Memorial Day Poems Prayers
Happy Memorial Day Wishes

pro said...

Fathers is going to take place on 18th June 2017. Here is best collection
Fathers Day Quotes

Fathers Day Images

Fathers Day Quotes From Son

Fathers Day Wishes

Unknown said...

Fathers Day Banner Images
Fathers Day Clipart Pictures
Happy Fathers Day Images

Unknown said...


Shab e qadr dua in Hindi


Shab E Qadr Pictures

4th Of July Celebration said...

Happy 4th Of July 2017 Quotes
Alameda 4th of July parade 2017
4th Of July Desserts

Unknown said...

Happy 4th of July Images
4th of July Quotes

4th of July Quotes To Everyone

Unknown said...


As India celebrates its 70th Independence Day on 15 August 2017, its citizens rejoice celebrating a different kind of freedom - the freedom to travel, explore, and unwind. The Indian citizens are all perked up for a much awaited long weekend during Independence Day.
Please visit Independence Day

India is known worldwide for its rich heritage and cultural beliefs. For the richness and sweetness attained, the country pays tribute to various people who played an influential role in this attainment.
Please visit Independence Day Status

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Stories Bunch said...

Friendship Day 

Friendship Day 2017

Happy Friendship Day 

Happy Friendship Day 2017

Unknown said...

Happy Independence Day, India - the "land of the free, and the home of the brave"! How well do you remember August 15th? Ask a youngster about the significance of Independence Day, and on that day prime minister of india give speech at red fort.
Please visit Independence Day Speech

Independence Day is celebrated differently and on difference dates around the world. There are fun traditions and ways to take this holiday. Find ideas about Independence Day Images, Quotes, Speech, Wishes, Status and Celebration,etc. For more...
Please visit Independence Day Images

Anonymous said...

You can buy from our large and diverse collection of salwar kameez, party wear suits, Bollywood collection, cotton Kurtis, Anarkali suits, Bollywood saree and many other products.....
We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
Plz visit:- Sarees

Anonymous said...

Designer Sarees is perhaps the desire of every single girl in this world to look amazing on her wedding day.
It is certainly important that the bride must be the star of the show.The most beautiful woman at the wedding venue.
In India,Designer Sarees are the most obvious choice for the Young Ladies.There are many Designer Sarees in our site...
For more...
Plz visit:- Sarees

An adorable personality partnered with a perfect choice for designer Sarees unbeatable.
Even before the blossom of modernization in Indian culture, kurta, sarees, and shalwar kameez had been part of India's unique civilization.
In India,Designer Sarees are the most obvious choice for the Young Ladies.There are many Designer Sarees in our site...
For more...
Plz visit:- Sarees

Niya Shah said...

A movie is used for an entertainment of busy people.
By seeing movie person experiences refreshment from their day to day life.
For watching movie plz visit following site:-
kingsman: the golden circle full movie online watch free
kingsman: the golden circle full movie download torrent

top 10 said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Ananta Dev said...

Hi do check out this latest post with our New Blog Post and I hope you would have enjoyed all our post
the Voice winner 2018
who wins the Voice 2018
the Voice Season 14 who will win
the Voice winner 2018
the Voice winner 2018
the Voice USA who will win
American got Talent Start Date
Boston Marathon Winner Results
Dancing with the stars winner name
who won the Voice UK
who will win the Voice UK
The Voice UK Winner Name
The Voice Australia premiere Start Date
The Voice Australia Winner Name
The Voice Australia Blind Audition Episodes
American Idol Episodes Winner Spoiler
American Idol Spoiler Start Date Schedule
American Idol Spoiler Winner Predictions
American Idol Episodes Winner Spoiler
American Idol Spoiler Start Date Schedule
American Idol Spoiler Winner Predictions

top 10 said...

Hi do check out this latest post with our New Blog Post and I hope you would have enjoyed all our post
American idol Finale Winner Predictions
American idol Winner Name Announced who won the Final
American idol 2018 who will win Predictions
American idol 2018 Finale Winner Spoiler
American Idol Winner tonight Full Episodes
American idol Finale Winner Predictions
American idol Winner Name Announced who won the Final
American idol 2018 who will win Predictions
American idol 2018 Finale Winner Spoiler
American Idol Winner tonight Full Episodes

WhatsApp status said...

Awesome Article, I love to read your Blog

Anonymous said...

Software

johnroy said...

Happy Fathers Day Messages
Fathers Day Funny Meme

Unknown said...

If you are looking for Quotes then check our latest collection of
Independence Day Images
4th Of July Quotes Messages
Messages For 4th Of July

Anonymous said...

USA Flags Clipart Images
4th of July Wishes Messages

Anonymous said...

Fourth Of July Greetings

Anonymous said...

framaroot
free movies and tv shows for android
TutuApp APK 2.3.18

Clara said...

This is extremely awesome article and instructive post mercifully check
My Website

Unknown said...

Happy Holi Shayari
Happy Holi Photos 2019
Happy Holi Messages 2019

Unknown said...

Europe Dmc In Delhi

colormax said...

Who Will Win Today Match Prediction Raja Babu
Check out ICC Crciket World Cup 2019 Schedule
Check Happy Fathers Day Images 2019
Check Happy Fathers Day Brother

Softwares Cracks said...

I have to search sites with relevant information on given topic and provide them to teacher our opinion and the article.
Foxit phantomPDF standard free download with crack

Anonymous said...

I wanted to thank you for this excellent read !! I definitely loved every little bit of it. I have you bookmarked your site to check out the new stuff you post.
Independence Day USA Images Free
Fourth of July Pics
4th of July Images Free
Happy 4th of July Pics

arun said...


kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees
kanchipuram silk sarees

preaqctivator said...

I have to search sites with relevant information on given topic and provide them to teacher our opinion and the article.
PowerISO Crack

Milan Arora said...

Click Here
Back Brace
posture corrector
posture corrector
posture corrector brace
click here
back brace
Back Brace

Milan Arora said...

site
Posture Corrector
click here
click here

Download said...

4k video downloader crack + License key.
IDM Crack + Serial Number Free.
Windows 10 Activator.
Windows 7 Activator.
Bandicam Crack + Serial Number.
WinRAR Crack + License key.
Microsoft Office Download

Milan Arora said...

kitchen chimney
Chimney
official site
official site
see this
kitchen chimney
have a look
chimney

Milan Arora said...

washing machine
top load washing machine
click here
washing machine india
official site
best top load machine
official site
click here

Anonymous said...

I think the admin in this site work very hard, because the themes and colours use in this site is very fantastic. Thanks for sharing.
reflector mac crack

Grety Pos said...

Very interesting , good job and thanks for sharing such a good blog, for know more related to hp printer setup 123 hp setup

Harry Oscar said...

Superb Content It is
DLL Files Fixer 2021 Crack
Sylenth1 Crack
Apeaksoft DVD Creator Crack

upmypc said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

upmypc said...

Thanks for provide great informatic and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things i never imagined and i would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thanks you once agian

taihir said...

Thanks for sharing such great information, I highly appreciate your hard-working skills which are quite beneficial for me.

raheelpc said...

Thanks for this post, I really found this very helpful. And blog about best time to post on cuber law is very useful. tweakbitn pcrepairkit crack

raheelpc said...


Amazing blog! I really like the way you explained such information about this post with us. And blog is really helpful for us. raheelpc

taihir said...

Such a nice and helpful piece of information. I’m so happy that you shared this helpful information with us. Please keep us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing. Folder Lock Crack

upmypc said...

I really enjoy reading your post about this Posting. This sort of clever work and coverage! Keep up the wonderful works guys, thanks for sharing this website

freeprokeys said...

autopano-video-pro-crack
is a networking material program. Videos will be press record formats and also reflect the caliber of information material and the type. Autopano video clip Pro is just a program that provides the freedom to approach and release and capture pics to videographers' game.new crack

abbas said...

Thanks for sharing such great information, I highly appreciate your hard-working skills which are quite beneficial for me. upmypc

ILYAS HAPPY said...

Thanks for sharing such great information, I highly appreciate your hard-working skills which are quite beneficial for me idmcracksetup.com

abbas said...

Thanks for providing great information and looking beautiful blog, really nice required information & the things I never imagined and I would request, wright more blog and blog post like that for us. Thank you once again driver-toolkit-crack

idmcrack said...

Thanks for this post, I really found this very helpful. And blog about best time to post on cuber law is very useful. sparkol-videoscribe-crack

up4pc said...

Thanks for the post. Very interesting post. This is my first-time visit here. I found so many interesting stuff in your blog. Keep posting..driver-genius-pro-20-0-0-135-crack-with-license-key-free-download/

Cracked Apps said...

This is a topic which is near to my heart.I appreciate you sharing this blog.Really thank you! Great.
PowerISO Crack
HitmanPro Crack
iMazing Crack
NSB Appstudio Crack
TeamViewer Crack
Avast Premium Crack
AVG Internet Security Crack
Movavi Video Converter Crack

Jonny Sin said...

youtube by click crack

saqlain said...

Acronis True Image Crack
UltraISO Premium Edition Crack

Hdpcgames said...

Tom Clancys Splinter Cell Download Free
Adobe Illustrator License file
Guitar Pro Keygen
SpyNote RAT Free Download
Any Video Converter Ultimate Keygen
Best Korean Comedy Movies
Full body massage bayside

tayyabjavaid said...

Axure Rp Pro Crack
Iskysoft Imedia Converter Deluxe Crack
Cracks
Roguekiller Crack
Guitar Pro Crack
Acronis True Image Crack

Zaki Saanvi said...

I have seen your writing skills. Your writing skills are very amazing. I also like your writing skills very much. I think you are a heavy and an old blogger. Thanks for sharing it with us.
Microsoft Office Crack
Kutool For Excel Crack
Download TC Games Crack
quicktime pro registration key
airparrot crack torrent
ummy video downloader license key free
stata free download full version with crack
bluebeam revu crack

newcrackkey said...

microsoft-office-2007-free-download-crack

cracklike said...

I have seen your writing skills. Your writing skills are very amazing. I also like your writing skills very much.
I think you are a heavy and an old blogger. Keep it up and keep sharing this type of posts with us.
rhinoceros crack
master pdf editor crack
bytefence crack
minitool partition wizard pro crack
unity pro crack
Crack Like

123-hpsmart said...

Thanks for sharing this useful information.

Need assistance for 123.hp.com/setup printer? We are provide extensive solution for hp printer setup, driver install and wifi setup. Visit us to our website.

HP Envy 6055e Wifi Setup
HP Envy Photo 7858 Wifi Setup

abdul sattar said...

Create message. Keep posting this kind of information on your blog.
I am very impressed with your site.
Hi, you've done a great job. I will definitely dig in and personally recommend it to my friends.
I am sure they will find this site useful.
avg virus definitions crack
tweakbit fixmypc crack
aida64 extreme edition crack
microsoft office 2010 product key crack

abbas said...

dbpoweramp-music-converter-crack

Bhailog said...

It was just as enjoyable for me as it was for you.
I like the drawing and your writing style.
Please continue to shake to your heart's content.
Here are the details: uncomfortably quick, but no doubt
again, as is virtually often the case if you promote this stroll inside.
iexplorer crack keygen
windows 8 enterprise crack
morphvox pro crack
speedify crack

THIS IS MY SITE said...

You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be really something which I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and very broad for me. I am looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it!

성인야설
립카페
마사지블루
건마탑
바카라사이트

casinositezone∞com said...

Your way of telling everything in this article is genuinely pleasant, all can easily understand it, Thanks a lot

토토

sportstototopcom said...

I really enjoyed reading this post, I always appreciate topics like this being discussed to us. Information very nice. I will follow post Thanks for sharinI really enjoyed reading this post, I always appreciate topics like this being discussed to us.

VISIT: 토토

Sabir said...

Thanks for the wonderful message! I really enjoyed reading
You can be a good writer. Bad Alvzis Blog and Testament
He'll be back later. I want to argue
Keep up the good work, have a great weekend!
And I appreciate your work, I'm a great blogger.
This article bothered me a lot.
I will bookmark your site and continue searching for new information.
camstudio crack
adobe after effects cc crack
gameloop crack
zebra cardstudio professional crack ss

bosssss said...

I guess I am the only one who came here to share my very own experience. Guess what!? I am using my laptop for almost the past 2 years, but I had no idea of solving some basic issues. I do not know how to Crack Softwares Free Download But thankfully, I recently visited a website named Crackedfine
Youtube By Click Crack
Reaper Crack
Windows 11 Activator Crack
Expressvpn Premium Crack

dipanshu sharma said...

Good Post! Thank you so much for sharing this pretty post, it was so good to read and useful to improve my knowledge as updated one, keep blogging.
Apply for Work Permit in Canada

Rohan Dave said...

Thank you for such valuable information about The First Law of Motion, if you would like to know more about the best schools in Bengaluru, visit schools in yelahanka

freeactivationkey said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Swaraj 724 XM said...

Nice Information About Netwon Motion Laws